Membership Fees Became HSA-Eligible in 2026. The $150 Cap Is Where PMHNP Practices Get Caught.

·

If you charge a monthly membership fee — or you have been sketching one on a napkin for the last six months — a tax provision that took effect on January 1 changed the math. Quietly. Without a single headline in the psychiatric press.

Here is the short version. Patients can now pay a direct primary care membership fee with health savings account dollars, and that fee no longer wrecks their ability to contribute to the HSA in the first place. That is a meaningful sweetener for a cash-pay practice. But the rule comes with a fee cap of $150 a month, a “sole compensation” requirement that most psychiatric membership models violate on day one, and a definition of who counts as a “primary care practitioner” that PMHNPs land inside almost by accident.

Getting this right is worth real money. Getting it wrong means telling a patient their fee is HSA-eligible when it is not, which is a marketing claim you do not want to defend.

What actually changed

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act, enacted July 4, 2025, amended Section 223 of the Internal Revenue Code in three ways that matter to anyone running an outpatient practice. Section 71308 is the one everybody is talking about: it tells the IRS to disregard a qualifying direct primary care service arrangement when deciding whether someone is eligible to contribute to an HSA. Before this, a DPC membership was treated as “other health plan” coverage. If your patient had a high-deductible plan and paid you $200 a month for unlimited access, they were technically disqualified from putting a dime into their HSA that year. Most of them had no idea.

The IRS filled in the technical detail in Notice 2026-5, released in December and effective for months beginning after December 31, 2025. The Treasury took public comments through March 6, so more guidance is plausible. What we have now is workable but not final, and that distinction should shape how confidently you talk about it.

Empty outpatient waiting room in early morning light

Two companion provisions widen the pool of patients who are even in this conversation. Section 71307 treats Bronze and Catastrophic exchange plans as high-deductible health plans, which pulls a large group of self-employed and gig-economy patients into HSA eligibility for the first time. Section 71306 makes the pandemic-era telehealth safe harbor permanent, so a plan can cover remote care before the deductible is met without losing HDHP status — retroactive to plan years beginning after December 31, 2024. If your panel skews toward freelancers, small-business owners, and people who buy their own coverage, more of them are walking in with an HSA card than were a year ago.

The four tests, and where psychiatry gets stuck

To be an HSA-compatible direct primary care service arrangement, all four of these have to be true at once:

  1. The arrangement provides medical care consisting solely of primary care services delivered by primary care practitioners.
  2. It excludes procedures requiring general anesthesia, prescription drugs other than vaccines, and laboratory services not typically administered in an ambulatory primary care setting.
  3. The sole compensation is a fixed periodic fee.
  4. The aggregate fee does not exceed $150 per month for one person, or $300 for an arrangement covering more than one, indexed for inflation after 2026.

Test one is where PMHNPs get an unexpectedly friendly answer. Notice 2026-5 defines “primary care practitioner” by pointing at Section 1833(x)(2)(A) of the Social Security Act — the same definition Medicare has used for years in its primary care incentive programs. That provision lists physicians with a primary specialty designation in family medicine, internal medicine, geriatric medicine, or pediatric medicine. Then, separately, it lists nurse practitioners, clinical nurse specialists, and physician assistants. The specialty filter is attached to the physician category. It is not attached to the NP category.

Read literally, a psychiatric mental health nurse practitioner is a nurse practitioner, full stop, and therefore a primary care practitioner for this purpose. A board-certified psychiatrist is not, because psychiatry is not one of the four listed physician specialties. That is an odd result, and I would not build a business on it without running it past a tax professional first. But it is what the text says, and it is the reason this provision is worth twenty minutes of your attention rather than none.

The prescription drug exclusion is narrower than it sounds

Test two stops a lot of people cold. “Primary care services do not include prescription drugs other than vaccines” reads, on first pass, like a wholesale exclusion of medication management — which would be the entire value of most psychiatric memberships.

The better reading is that the exclusion targets what the arrangement furnishes, not what the clinician decides. Direct primary care practices commonly dispense medications in-office at wholesale cost as part of the membership. That is what Congress carved out. Writing a prescription that the patient fills at their own pharmacy, using their own coverage, is a clinical service — the evaluation and the decision — not a drug provided by the arrangement.

The IRS did not spell this out, and it declined to tie the service definition to HCPCS codes, which would have made the line easier to draw. So this is the single question to put in writing to your CPA before you advertise anything. If you keep a stock of samples or dispense anything on site, that changes the analysis and probably not in your favor.

Antique brass balance scale weighing a small stack of coins

“Sole compensation” is the quiet deal-breaker

Test three is where most psychiatric membership models fall apart, and it has nothing to do with psychiatry.

HUB International’s benefits compliance team laid out a clean example in an August 2025 bulletin. A practice charging $100 a month with no other charges, where a patient can come in three times in July and pay nothing beyond the membership, qualifies. A practice charging an annual access fee and billing for each visit does not — regardless of how reasonable that structure is, and regardless of whether the visits are billed to insurance or to the patient.

Look at how most psychiatric membership practices are actually built. A monthly fee that covers messaging, refills, and care coordination, plus a per-session charge for the actual appointment. Or a membership that runs alongside insurance billing for the medication management visits. Both are sensible businesses. Neither is a direct primary care service arrangement under this statute. The word “solely” is doing a lot of work, and the IRS has given no indication it plans to soften it.

The $150 cap, and what happens when you blow past it

Here is the part that will decide this for most of you. The cap is $150 per month for an individual. Psychiatric membership practices routinely charge $250 to $400, and for good reason — panel sizes are smaller, visits are longer, and the after-hours load is heavier than in primary care.

The consequences of exceeding the cap are more interesting than a flat disqualification. If your arrangement otherwise meets the definition but the fee runs above $150, two things happen. Your patient’s fee is still a qualified medical expense they can reimburse from an existing HSA. But the arrangement remains disqualifying coverage, which means they cannot make new contributions to that HSA while they are enrolled with you.

Translate that into a conversation. A patient with a funded HSA and no plans to add to it this year loses nothing by joining a $300-a-month practice — they can spend the balance on you. A patient who is actively saving, especially one maxing out contributions for the tax deduction, faces a real trade-off. That is a five-sentence explanation you should have ready, not a surprise they discover at tax time.

Two more details worth knowing. Membership fees do not count toward the patient’s deductible or out-of-pocket maximum. And if an employer pays the fee, including through a cafeteria plan salary reduction, it is excludable compensation under Section 106 and cannot also be treated as the employee’s HSA-qualified expense. No double-dipping.

Open cedar gate in a dry-stone wall at golden hour

What to do in the next two weeks

Audit your fee structure against test three. Pull up your membership agreement and find every line where money changes hands. Any per-visit charge, any no-show fee, any insurance billing alongside the membership, and you are outside the definition. That is not a crisis — it just means you stop describing the fee as HSA-compatible.

Fix your website language before anything else. “HSA-eligible” on a pricing page is a claim, and the FTC spent this summer demonstrating it takes claims on healthcare marketing pages seriously. If your arrangement qualifies, say so with the conditions attached. If it does not, the accurate and still-useful line is that patients may be able to reimburse fees from an existing HSA and should confirm with their own tax advisor. Vague is safer than wrong, and honest is better than both.

Send one email to your CPA. Three questions: does my structure satisfy the sole-compensation requirement, does psychiatric medication management count as a primary care service when I am not dispensing anything, and does my fee level put patients over the cap. Ask for the answer in writing. This is not settled law, and you want a paper trail showing you asked.

Decide whether the cap is worth designing around. A $150 tier that covers messaging, refills, and brief check-ins, sold separately from longer visits, would not qualify — the separate visit charge breaks it. But a genuinely all-inclusive $150 membership for a stable maintenance panel might pencil out, particularly if it fills the schedule gaps that no-shows leave behind. Run the numbers before you dismiss it.

The bigger point

Nothing in this provision was written with psychiatry in mind. Congress was thinking about family medicine practices in small towns, and the drafting shows it. But the definition of “primary care practitioner” swept nurse practitioners in without qualification, and that is a genuine, if accidental, advantage for PMHNPs over psychiatrist-owned membership practices.

Whether it turns into anything depends on details that are entirely within your control: how you structure the fee, what you promise in the agreement, and how carefully you describe it to patients. Those are the same three things that determine whether any cash-pay model survives its first audit.

None of this is tax advice, and I am not your accountant. It is a map of where the questions are.

If you are building or rebuilding the practice website that has to explain any of this to patients in plain language — pricing, membership terms, what insurance you do and do not take — that is exactly the kind of thing we help PMHNPs get right at pmhnpwebsite.com.