The decision usually arrives quietly. Your waitlist is eight weeks deep, you have turned away three referrals this month, and a PMHNP you trained with texts to ask whether you are taking on anyone. Within a week you are drafting an agreement. And because every practice owner you know did it this way, you write the words “independent contractor” at the top.
That single choice — made in an afternoon, usually without a lawyer — carries more financial risk than almost anything else in the first three years of a psychiatric practice. And in 2026, the ground under it shifted twice.
Why 1099 became the default in behavioral health
The appeal is not mysterious. A contractor arrangement lets you pay a percentage of collections instead of a salary, which means you are never writing a check for hours that did not generate revenue. In a specialty where no-show rates run high — Tebra’s analysis of behavioral health scheduling data puts typical clinic rates well above those in primary care, often in the 15 to 25 percent range — that protection feels essential. You avoid payroll taxes, unemployment insurance, workers’ compensation, and the administrative weight of running payroll for one person.
There is also a supply-side reason. Psychiatric clinicians are scarce and mobile. Many PMHNPs genuinely want contractor status so they can hold panels at two or three practices and keep their schedules flexible. When both parties want the same label, nobody pushes back.
The problem is that neither party’s preference is legally relevant. The IRS and the Department of Labor both look past what the agreement says to what the relationship actually is.

What changed in 2026
Two developments matter for practice owners planning a hire this year.
First, the reporting threshold. Beginning with 2026 payments, the 1099-NEC filing threshold rose from $600 to $2,000 per contractor per year. On its face this is administrative relief. In practice it has created a dangerous misreading: some owners have concluded that smaller contractor payments are now invisible, or that the change signals a loosening of classification rules generally. It does not. The threshold governs when a form must be filed. It says nothing about whether the worker was properly classified in the first place. A misclassified clinician you never issued a 1099 to is not a smaller problem — it is the same problem with less paperwork.
Second, and more consequential, the Department of Labor published a proposed rule in the Federal Register on February 27, 2026 that would rescind the 2024 independent contractor regulation and return to a streamlined five-factor economic reality test. Under the proposal, two factors carry more weight than the rest: the nature and degree of control over the work, and the worker’s opportunity for profit or loss based on their own initiative or investment. The comment period closed April 28, 2026.
Here is the part practice owners keep missing. Until that rescission is finalized, the 2024 totality-of-the-circumstances rule remains the operative standard under the Fair Labor Standards Act. You are, at this moment, operating under a rule that is on its way out but has not left. Firms tracking the rulemaking — Jackson Lewis and Nixon Peabody among them — have flagged the same practical point: a classification decision you make in 2026 will be judged under whichever framework applies when a claim is filed, which may not be the one you were reading about when you signed the agreement.
The safest response is not to bet on the friendlier standard. It is to build an arrangement that survives either one.
The three tests you are actually being graded on
There is no single classification rule. There are at least three, and they can produce different answers about the same clinician.
The IRS applies a common-law analysis organized around three categories: behavioral control (does the practice direct how the work is performed), financial control (who controls the business side — investment, unreimbursed expenses, opportunity for loss), and the type of relationship (written contracts, benefits, permanence, and whether the services are a key aspect of the business).
The Department of Labor applies the FLSA economic reality test, which asks a broader question: is this worker economically dependent on your practice, or are they genuinely in business for themselves?
Then there is your state. A meaningful number of states use some version of the ABC test, and its middle prong is the one that should keep psychiatric practice owners up at night. The B prong typically requires that the work performed fall outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business. A PMHNP practice hiring a PMHNP to see psychiatric patients cannot satisfy that. Not with better contract language, not with a longer arbitration clause. In ABC-test states, the arrangement is structurally indefensible for clinical staff, and the only question is whether anyone looks.

Where psychiatric practices specifically get caught
Generic classification advice does not map cleanly onto a mental health practice, because several things we consider ordinary clinical hygiene read as employer control.
Supervision and collaboration. In the 23 states that still require a collaborating physician or some form of practice agreement, the supervisory structure your state mandates can look exactly like the behavioral control the IRS is scanning for. You are caught between two regulators asking for opposite things. The workaround is documentation: make clear in writing which oversight elements exist because state law compels them, and keep those separate from the day-to-day direction you give.
Your EHR and your scheduling. A contractor who uses your EHR license, your intake forms, your template library, and your front-desk staff to fill their calendar is not investing in their own business. They are using yours. This is the most common failure point, and it is the one that shows up plainly in a payroll audit.
Group NPI billing. If claims go out under your group NPI, with your tax ID and your contracted rates, the clinician has no independent opportunity for profit or loss. Their income is a function of your contracts. Under the DOL’s proposed core factors, that alone is heavy weight on the employee side.
Non-competes and exclusivity. A restrictive covenant that prevents your contractor from practicing elsewhere is close to self-defeating. You are contractually establishing the economic dependence the test is looking for.
Set hours. “Tuesdays and Thursdays, 9 to 5, in this office” is a schedule. Schedules belong to employees.

What it costs to be wrong
Misclassification exposure is not one bill. It is several, arriving from different agencies over different timelines.
There is the federal piece: unpaid employment taxes, the employer share of FICA you never remitted, interest, and penalties. Section 530 relief can soften this if you had a reasonable basis and treated similar workers consistently — but that relief evaporates if the conduct is found willful. There is the state piece: unemployment insurance assessments and workers’ compensation exposure, and state labor agencies often move faster than the IRS because a single unemployment claim from a departed clinician triggers a review. And there is the private piece: an FLSA claim for overtime and minimum wage, with a two- or three-year lookback and, in many cases, liquidated damages that double it.
Practitioner-facing analyses generally put the average per-worker cost of a misclassification finding in the five figures, with severe or willful cases running far higher. For a practice with four contractors and three years of history, the arithmetic gets ugly quickly — and it lands at the moment a clinician leaves unhappy, which is precisely when your cash position is already strained.
What a defensible arrangement actually looks like
If you want to keep a contractor model, the relationship has to be built to match the label. That means the clinician carries their own malpractice policy, is credentialed under their own NPI where the payer allows it, sets their own schedule and rates, uses their own EHR or licenses yours at market cost, works with other practices, and can decline referrals. They should have real, documented business expenses. They should be able to lose money.
Most PMHNP practice owners, reading that list honestly, will recognize that it does not describe what they built. That is useful information, not a failure.
The W-2 alternative is more expensive than the sticker price suggests but less expensive than owners assume. Employer FICA is 7.65 percent, unemployment insurance is usually a modest percentage of the first several thousand dollars of wages, and workers’ compensation for outpatient behavioral health is among the cheaper classifications there is. Payroll services for a two-clinician practice run well under $100 a month. Against that, you get something worth real money: the ability to require documentation standards, set availability, enforce a shared no-show policy, and build the kind of process consistency that makes a practice sellable later.
A middle path exists too. Some owners keep a genuinely part-time, genuinely independent contractor for overflow — a clinician with their own established panel who takes occasional referrals — while bringing core clinical staff on as employees. That structure is defensible because it reflects two different economic realities, and it is documented as such.
The move to make this month
Pull every contractor agreement you currently have. For each clinician, write down who controls the schedule, whose EHR they use, whose NPI the claims go out under, whether they practice anywhere else, and whether they could lose money in a bad month. Then look at the pattern rather than the paperwork.
If the answers point toward employment, talk to a healthcare employment attorney and a CPA who works with practices in your state before you talk to your clinician. Voluntary correction programs exist and are meaningfully cheaper than a finding. Retroactive fixes are almost always less expensive than defended ones.
None of this is legal or tax advice, and classification is genuinely state-specific — the same arrangement can be clean in one jurisdiction and indefensible across a border. But this is the kind of decision where an hour of professional time in year one prevents a five-figure problem in year four.
Building a practice means making a hundred structural decisions that nobody teaches in a PMHNP program. For more practical guidance on starting, running, and growing a psychiatric private practice, visit pmhnpwebsite.com.
